| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Cook, Sinead A (17)
|
NJBB |
4:42.71 |
4:43.51 |
0.80 |
| 2 |
Murray, Caroline C (18)
|
NJCAT |
4:41.53 |
4:49.34 |
7.81 |
| 3 |
Joss, Zoe T (17)
|
NJCAT |
4:55.10 |
4:51.25 |
-3.85 |
| 4 |
Dollard, Avery C (17)
|
NJCAT |
4:46.66 |
4:54.91 |
8.25 |
| 5 |
Okawa-O'Connell, Coco N (16)
|
NJCAT |
4:58.02 |
5:02.09 |
4.07 |
| 6 |
English, Eliana L (15)
|
NJBB |
5:43.22 |
5:15.72 |
-27.50 |
| 7 |
Jagen, Sonia I (15)
|
NJCAT |
5:35.00 |
5:28.71 |
-6.29 |
| 8 |
Cialdella, Gabrielle (15)
|
NJBWTD |
5:44.99 |
6:06.99 |
22.00 |
|
Ramos, Vivianna Y (15)
|
NJCAT |
5:20.15 |
NS |
- |
|
Zuluaga, Sophie R (16)
|
NJCAT |
4:51.10 |
NS |
- |