| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Kroll, Matthew J (12)
|
NCMAC |
4:42.48 |
4:33.14 |
-9.34 |
| 2 |
Grottle, Benjamin A (12)
|
GADYNA |
4:45.29 |
4:33.29 |
-12.00 |
| 3 |
Garcia, Gabriel O (12)
|
NCMAC |
4:54.75 |
5:02.93 |
8.18 |
| 4 |
Thornhill, Kwame W (12)
|
NCMAC |
5:07.27 |
5:05.45 |
-1.82 |
| 5 |
Wasmuth, Edward H (12)
|
GADYNA |
5:42.93 |
5:05.95 |
-36.98 |
| 6 |
Muhammad, Idris I (12)
|
GADYNA |
5:20.20 |
5:07.10 |
-13.10 |
| 7 |
Flickinger, Tyler J (12)
|
NCMAC |
5:09.06 |
5:09.00 |
-0.06 |
| 8 |
Altera, Ryan (12)
|
GADYNA |
5:08.69 |
5:09.26 |
0.57 |
| 9 |
VanValkenburg, Jack E (12)
|
GADYNA |
5:23.19 |
5:09.31 |
-13.88 |
| 10 |
Bradshaw, Lane M (11)
|
NCMAC |
5:13.38 |
5:10.27 |
-3.11 |
| 11 |
Washington, Sebastian L (11)
|
GADYNA |
|
5:21.06 |
- |
| 12 |
Daniels, Noah E (12)
|
GADYNA |
5:23.69 |
5:25.15 |
1.46 |
| 13 |
Bruno, Matthew S (11)
|
GADYNA |
6:21.67 |
5:30.33 |
-51.34 |
| 14 |
Holder, Deaven M (11)
|
NCMAC |
|
5:44.46 |
- |
| 15 |
Foelske, Bastian P (11)
|
GADYNA |
|
5:49.68 |
- |
| 16 |
Keen, Troy D (10)
|
NCMAC |
|
5:50.61 |
- |
| 17 |
Bonoffski, Preston M (11)
|
NCMAC |
|
5:52.41 |
- |
| 18 |
Nixon, Connor S (11)
|
GADYNA |
5:50.23 |
6:00.29 |
10.06 |