| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
El Ghissassi, Awab (12)
|
NIVEST |
4:59.06 |
4:58.72 |
-0.34 |
| 2 |
Durr, Tucker C (12)
|
ADSCHE |
5:01.62 |
5:02.70 |
1.08 |
| 3 |
Nelson, Quinn M (12)
|
ADSCHE |
5:01.27 |
5:14.24 |
12.97 |
| 4 |
Di Fabio, Luka D (11)
|
ADSCHE |
5:34.71 |
5:28.16 |
-6.55 |
| 5 |
Gregory, John D (11)
|
ADSCHE |
5:22.74 |
5:28.37 |
5.63 |
| 6 |
Lewis, Matthew K (12)
|
NIVICT |
5:24.52 |
5:35.84 |
11.32 |
| 7 |
Weber, Stefan S (11)
|
CTRAC |
5:49.41 |
5:43.09 |
-6.32 |
| 8 |
VanAlst, Amon J (12)
|
ADUN |
6:03.68 |
5:51.84 |
-11.84 |
| 9 |
Lewis, Christopher J (11)
|
NIVICT |
6:01.99 |
5:59.89 |
-2.10 |
| 10 |
Weber, Maximilian F (9)
|
CTUN |
6:50.99 |
6:03.19 |
-47.80 |
| 11 |
Wakelee, Adam R (11)
|
NIVICT |
5:48.66 |
6:03.41 |
14.75 |
| 12 |
Reichl, Dylan J (12)
|
ADBFIN |
6:11.97 |
6:04.02 |
-7.95 |
| 13 |
Boenau, Tyler F (10)
|
ADBFIN |
6:27.69 |
6:33.68 |
5.99 |
| 14 |
Bewlay, Charles E (9)
|
ADSCHE |
6:30.00 |
6:34.67 |
4.67 |
| 15 |
Leanza, Christopher M (12)
|
ADSCHE |
6:30.00 |
6:58.02 |
28.02 |