| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Johnston, Sabrina K (15)
|
MRBGNW |
5:03.44 |
5:11.49 |
8.05 |
| 2 |
Nadecki, Grace (15)
|
MRBGNW |
5:24.79 |
5:32.55 |
7.76 |
| 3 |
Wohl, Katharine A (17)
|
MRBGNW |
5:19.43 |
5:38.98 |
19.55 |
| 4 |
Blakeslee, Kaitlin P (16)
|
MRBGNW |
5:30.50 |
5:46.17 |
15.67 |
| 5 |
Alexander, Sinceraty D (16)
|
MRBGNW |
5:34.88 |
5:52.56 |
17.68 |
| 6 |
McIntyre, Savannah (15)
|
MRBGNW |
6:03.05 |
5:54.22 |
-8.83 |
| 7 |
Patterson, Clare M (15)
|
MRBGNW |
5:51.94 |
5:54.61 |
2.67 |
| 8 |
Saric, Juliana M (17)
|
MRPAC |
5:49.14 |
6:08.69 |
19.55 |
| 9 |
Morr, Isabelle N (15)
|
MRPAC |
6:12.09 |
6:13.39 |
1.30 |
| 10 |
Ford, Sydney (18)
|
MRBGNW |
5:45.84 |
6:17.12 |
31.28 |
| 11 |
Conti, Gabriella A (15)
|
MRPAC |
5:41.11 |
6:25.62 |
44.51 |
| 12 |
Pierro, Alyssa A (15)
|
MRBGNW |
6:39.19 |
6:54.58 |
15.39 |