| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Smith, Jack G (14)
|
VACYAC |
4:21.09 |
4:22.82 |
1.73 |
| 2 |
Neuhaus, Harrison J (14)
|
VADC |
4:26.11 |
4:29.34 |
3.23 |
| 3 |
Alexander, Jonathan D (14)
|
VACYAC |
4:48.98 |
4:40.79 |
-8.19 |
| 4 |
Miller, Dean S (14)
|
VADC |
4:30.58 |
4:45.89 |
15.31 |
| 5 |
King, David W (14)
|
VACYAC |
5:16.14 |
4:47.19 |
-28.95 |
| 6 |
Schardt, James E (13)
|
VANOVA |
5:15.96 |
4:49.62 |
-26.34 |
| 7 |
Thornberry, Rowland W (13)
|
VAUN |
5:01.94 |
4:53.26 |
-8.68 |
| 8 |
DeVito, Graham S (14)
|
VACYAC |
4:55.02 |
4:55.31 |
0.29 |
| 9 |
Boyd, Aiden L (13)
|
VANOVA |
5:04.06 |
5:08.31 |
4.25 |
| 10 |
Fisher, Adam M (14)
|
VANOVA |
5:07.06 |
5:10.28 |
3.22 |
| 11 |
Downing, Aidan E (13)
|
VANOVA |
6:00.42 |
5:27.94 |
-32.48 |
| 12 |
Olson, Thomas S (13)
|
VACYAC |
|
5:38.18 |
- |
| 13 |
Kennedy, Daniel S (14)
|
VASRVA |
|
6:16.65 |
- |
|
Lane, Brennan W (14)
|
VASRVA |
5:29.22 |
DQ |
- |