| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Webber, Molly M (13)
|
NJMCSC |
5:00.82 |
4:51.17 |
-9.65 |
| 2 |
Gosnell, Laura (14)
|
NJMDY |
5:00.42 |
4:56.00 |
-4.42 |
| 3 |
Molinaro, Madison R (13)
|
NJMCSC |
5:06.01 |
5:06.36 |
0.35 |
| 4 |
Breslin, Julia K (13)
|
NJCAT |
5:10.92 |
5:08.98 |
-1.94 |
| 5 |
Lukonen, Sasha C (13)
|
NJCAT |
5:24.10 |
5:10.65 |
-13.45 |
| 6 |
Murphy, Heather N (14)
|
NJHACY |
5:03.28 |
5:10.97 |
7.69 |
| 7 |
Kutsup, Gabrielle A (13)
|
NJCAT |
5:22.95 |
5:10.99 |
-11.96 |
| 8 |
Webber, Cora R (12)
|
NJMCSC |
5:24.12 |
5:11.11 |
-13.01 |
| 9 |
Morehart, Cassandra S (13)
|
NJHACY |
5:18.79 |
5:21.90 |
3.11 |
| 10 |
Fueglistaler, Stephania L (12)
|
NJHACY |
5:28.89 |
5:24.47 |
-4.42 |
| 11 |
Schraven, Kiva (13)
|
NJMAY |
5:28.99 |
5:57.02 |
28.03 |